Calculate the True Cost of Fragmented Total Rewards

Your scattered compensation and benefits systems are costing you more than you realize. Quantify the hidden impact on attrition, underutilized programs, and HR productivity.

1. Avoidable Attrition Cost

Formula: (# of regrettable leavers × average salary × 1.4) × 5% (Conservative estimate of preventable departures through improved visibility)
$
Annual Attrition Cost
$70,000

2. Underutilized Benefits Cost

Formula: % unused × total benefits budget
$
%
Annual Underutilization Cost
$800,000

3. Administrative Burden Cost

Formula: HR hours per month × cost per hour × 12 months
hrs
$
Annual Administrative Cost
$57,600

Total Annual Cost of Fragmentation

$927,600
Attrition Costs
8%
Underutilization
86%
Admin Burden
6%

These Numbers Tell a Story

The numbers you see above represent what fragmented rewards systems are costing your organization right now in lost talent, wasted program spend, and HR hours consumed by manual work.

The good news? Organizations are solving this without ripping out existing systems. They’re creating unified visibility layers that pull compensation data from core HR systems and consolidate benefits information into one employee-facing platform.

That’s exactly what we built Total Rewards Hub to do: connect your existing systems and give employees one place to see their complete compensation package while eliminating the manual work that’s driving your costs.

How to Fix Fragmentation: 
The Complete Guide

Our 2026 Total Rewards Modernization Playbook walks you through the complete process, from assessing your current fragmentation to building your business case to implementing a unified solution. It includes real frameworks, step-by-step guidance, and examples from companies who’ve solved this problem.

Ready to talk solutions?

Schedule a consultation with our team to discuss how Total Rewards Hub can
connect your systems and eliminate fragmentation costs.


FAQ

What is Total Rewards fragmentation?

Total Rewards fragmentation happens when your employee benefits, compensation, and perks are scattered across multiple disconnected systems and spreadsheets. This makes it hard for employees to see their full package value and creates costly inefficiencies for HR teams.

How do I know if my Total Rewards are fragmented?

Common signs include: employees asking basic questions about their benefits, HR spending hours creating custom compensation statements, benefits going unused because people don’t know about them, and data living in multiple systems that don’t talk to each other.

How accurate is the Cost of Fragmentation Calculator?

The calculator uses standard cost estimation formulas based on HR industry benchmarks. Results will vary based on your specific inputs and organizational factors. Use it as a directional tool to understand potential fragmentation costs. We recommend validating the outputs with your finance and HR teams for your business case.

What data do I need to use this calculator?

You need six data points: number of regrettable employee departures, their average salary, your discretionary benefits budget, estimated unused benefits percentage, monthly HR admin hours, and HR cost per hour. Most of this comes from your HRIS and payroll systems.

Should I include all employees who left or just regrettable departures?

Only count regrettable departures – employees you wanted to keep who chose to leave. Exclude retirements, layoffs, performance terminations, and relocations since these aren’t preventable through better Total Rewards communication.

How can I reduce Total Rewards fragmentation costs?

The fastest way is implementing a unified Total Rewards platform that connects all your existing systems. This eliminates manual work, increases benefits visibility, and improves employee retention, typically reducing fragmentation costs by 50-70% in year one.

Can I reduce fragmentation costs without buying new technology?

You can make small improvements with benefits wikis and email campaigns, but these manual workarounds still require significant HR time and don’t solve the root problem. Most organizations find the time spent on workarounds exceeds the cost of a proper solution.

What is Semos Cloud’s Total Rewards Hub?

Semos Cloud’s Total Rewards Hub is a unified platform that consolidates all your employee compensation, benefits, equity, and perks data into one personalized employee experience. It integrates with your existing HR systems to eliminate fragmentation while keeping your current tech stack intact.

How is Total Rewards Hub different from an HRIS?

Your HRIS stores employee records and manages HR processes, it’s the system of record. Total Rewards Hub is the engagement layer that makes compensation and benefits visible, understandable, and personalized for employees. They work together, not as replacements.

What’s the difference between Total Rewards Hub and compensation benchmarking tools?

Benchmarking tools provide external market data to help HR set competitive salaries. Total Rewards Hub shows employees their complete personalized compensation package. Most companies use both: benchmarking informs strategy, Total Rewards Hub communicates it to employees.

How does Total Rewards Hub improve employee retention?

When employees can easily see their complete compensation value, including often-hidden benefits like employer 401k match, learning budgets, and wellness programs, they’re less likely to leave for a higher base salary elsewhere. Visibility drives retention.